Home / Review methodology

How we review products

Every score, ranking and comparison on VapeReviewHub comes from the same documented process. This page explains it, including what our method can’t show you.

Last updated

A desk with notes and a laptop used for research
  • SourcedEvery figure links to the maker or an independent source.
  • Published criteriaWeights are set and shown before any product is scored.
  • LabelledEach article says whether it is desk research or hands-on.
  • Corrected openlyFixes are dated and noted on the article.

Two kinds of review

We are open about how each review was made, because the method decides what the review can tell you.

Used in all current articles

Desk review

Built from the manufacturer’s published specifications, current list prices and independent coverage, each one cited.

It can tell you
What a product is, what the maker claims, and how it compares on paper with its rivals.
It can’t tell you
How the product performs in your hands, or whether the maker’s claims hold up in use.
None published yet

Hands-on review

A product we have used and measured ourselves. The article will name the tester and describe the testing.

It will state
Who tested it, for how long, how the product was obtained and what was measured.
Until then
We never describe a product as tested. If an article doesn’t say hands-on, it isn’t.

Our process

Every article goes through the same four stages, in this order.

  1. 1

    Collect

    We gather specifications, list prices and independent coverage, and record where each figure came from and the date we checked it.

    Result: a sourced fact sheet
  2. 2

    Cross-check

    A specification is used only if it traces back to the manufacturer or a second independent source. Anything we can’t confirm is marked as not verified, never estimated.

    Result: verified figures, gaps marked
  3. 3

    Score

    For rankings, the criteria and their weights are fixed before any product is scored, then applied the same way to every product.

    Result: scores anyone can recalculate
  4. 4

    Publish

    The article goes live with its sources, its limitations, a publication date and the date of its last update.

    Result: an article you can check

How scores work

Each product gets a score from 0 to 10 on every criterion. The overall score is the weighted average of those scores. If we couldn’t verify a criterion for a product, it is left out and the remaining weights are rescaled, so missing data neither helps nor hurts.

Example weights

From our personal air filter ranking

Rated filter life25%
Cost per 100 uses25%
Filter waste20%
Replaceable filter15%
Portability15%

Worked example: Sploofy V3

We couldn’t verify a current cartridge price, so cost isn’t scored. The other four criteria share the weight.

CriterionScoreWeightPoints
Filter life825200
Cost per 100 usesn/a––
Filter waste820160
Replaceable1015150
Portability51575
Total75585

585 ÷ 757.8out of 10

Our standards

We always

  • List a source for every factual claim.
  • Attribute manufacturer claims to the manufacturer.
  • Say when a figure couldn’t be verified.
  • Publish criteria and weights with every ranking.
  • Show publication and update dates.

We never

  • Invent test results, ratings or user reviews.
  • Publish safety ratings or health claims.
  • Change a score because a brand asks us to.
  • Accept payment or free products for coverage.
  • Let a brand see an article before publication.

Article labels

Each article carries one label, shown above its headline, so you know what kind of piece you are reading.

Desk review
An evaluation from published specifications and sources, without hands-on testing.
Comparison
Products set side by side on the same published data.
Ranking
Products scored on criteria and weights published in the article.
Guide
An explanation of how something works.
Report
News, stating facts without interpretation.
Analysis
Our interpretation of the facts, clearly marked as ours.
Opinion
A named writer’s view.

Spotted an error?

If a figure is wrong or out of date, tell us and include a link to your source. We check it, fix the article and add a dated note explaining what changed.